I'm making my way to the hockey rink, where we hold our annual Prize Assembly. Here, students and faculty are honored with awards for achievements in a variety of fields such as academics, athletics and even the arts. It's pretty cold in here, at least in comparison to how bright and sunny it is outside. I kind of like it though, the cheery, springy outdoors can be kind of overwhelming sometimes. I've come to these Prize Assemblies, and year after year I leave, feeling unaccomplished and incompetent. I work hard to be successful, I always have. I guess that's something that just comes along with being a self-critical overachiever with a high standards. Every time I make my way up onto the stage to receive my award, I feel a slight warmth inside me. Everyone at Kingswood Oxford is so friendly and caring. The praise I receive here is absolutely wonderful. I would think to myself, maybe I'm doing something right, maybe this will put me onto a path of grand success, maybe this is what I was "destined" to do However, no matter how inspired and satisfied I feel in the spur of the moment, there always is that underlying pessimism that shortly finds it's way into my head. I always remember the fact that there are so many achievements out there that I didn't meet the qualifications for. The smug, proud expressions on their faces just remind of how no matter how many times I succeed, these successes are always accompanied with even more failures. At this point, I've just started dreading coming to these functions, but no matter how much I argue with my mother, she always finds a way to get me to go.
Why should I be putting so much emphasis on such irrelevant and worthless achievements? These don't mean anything. They won't alter the patterns within the kaleidoscope of my life. For all I know, KO could just be awarding me because they feel bad for me. They know I don't deserve it; they see how much of a failure I truly am and so, in an attempt to show their commiserations, they create the delusion that I'm worthy of being rewarded for achievements that I didn't even effectuate. Nobody, not even someone who's as much of a disappointment like me, deserves such humiliation and ridicule. Maybe it's not even out of pity; maybe they're just trying to publicize how much of shameful dereliction I am by putting me on that stage, especially when I have no good reason for being on their in the first place.
Hi Gabrielle!
ReplyDeleteI like your story! I think you capture a lot of Esther's personality in this, although at times I think it gets a little more dark and philosophical than what Esther would say at times. Nice integration of the quote. Also, I think that during her phase of straight A's and awards she didn't feel much like a failure yet, but I like the pessimistic and analytical views. Good job!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Gabby,
ReplyDeleteYou do a great job of depicting Esther's simultaneous drive to succeed and her crippling self-consciousness. Your last paragraph does a particularly good job of showing her self-doubt. What other aspects of Esther's personality would be important to display during a prize assembly. What would she be most interested in winning? Consider her competitiveness. Your central metaphor of the kaleidoscope is a little hard to follow and can be developed a bit more.
Thank you for the feedback! Throughout my attempts to put my own twist on the narrative, I realize now that I kind of blocked out a big portion of Esther's own personality. I'll definitely take these comments and incorporate them in future writings :)
Delete